Gainesville Logo
 
File #: 180167.    Version: 1 Name:
Type: Staff Recommendation Status: Passed
File created: 7/3/2018 In control: Board of Trustees/Retiree Health Plan
On agenda: 8/2/2018 Final action: 8/2/2018
Title: Actuarial Services for the Gainesville Retiree Health Insurance Trust Fund (B)
Attachments: 1. 180167_A 180084-RFP Actuarial Svc Gen Emp Pen-Ret Hlth-FINAL-8.2.18.pdf, 2. 180167_B 180084-RFP for Actuarial Svc-ADD_1 FINAL-8.2.18.pdf, 3. 180167_C 180084-RFP for Actuarial Svc-ADD_2 FINAL-8.2.18.pdf, 4. 180167_D 180084-RFP for Actuarial Svc-BID RECORD-8.2.18.pdf, 5. 180167_E Aon Submittal-8.2.18.pdf, 6. 180167_F Boomershine Submittal-8.2.18.pdf, 7. 180167_G Foster & Foster Submittal-8.2.18.pdf, 8. 180167_H Gallagher Submittal-8.2.18.pdf, 9. 180167_i Nyhart Price Proposal-8.2.18.pdf, 10. 180167_J Nyhart Submittal-8.2.18.pdf, 11. 180167_K Segal Consulting Submittal-8.2.18.pdf, 12. 180167_L 180084-RFP for Actuarial Svc-EVAL WRITTEN summary-8.2.18.pdf, 13. 180167_M 180084-RFP for Actuarial Svc-EVAL WRITTEN_evaluator_1-8.2.18.pdf, 14. 180167_N 180084-RFP for Actuarial Svc-EVAL WRITTEN_evaluator_2-8.2.18.pdf, 15. 180167_O 180084-RFP for Actuarial Svc-EVAL WRITTEN_evaluator_3-8.2.18.pdf, 16. 180167_P 180084-RFP for Actuarial Svc-Bid Tabulation-Agenda Item backup-8.2.18.pdf, 17. 180167_Q 180084-RFP for Act Svc-AI backup-memo for recordings-Retiree Health.pdf
Title
Actuarial Services for the Gainesville Retiree Health Insurance Trust Fund (B)

Explanation
In 2016 the City’s Pensions & Investments Division conducted a Request for Proposal (RFP) for actuarial services for the Gainesville Retiree Health Insurance Trust Fund. The firm Xerox/Buck Consultants was selected to provide actuarial services through that RFP process. In 2017 Xerox/Buck Consultants had an ownership & name change to Conduent. In 2018 the Conduent actuarial team who had been working with the City left Conduent. That actuarial team had over 12 years of experience working with the City, and was the only group at Conduent who had experience working with Florida Public Pension Plans and the FL State Division of Retirement. Later in 2018, the City was notified that Conduent is being sold to a private equity firm. Given the organizational changes and staffing turnover, City staff felt that it was necessary to perform another RFP for actuarial services for the Gainesville Retiree Health Insurance Trust Fund.

Budget & Finance staff recently completed a request for proposals for Actuarial Services for the Gainesville Retiree Health Insurance Trust Fund to begin September 30, 2018. Ten actuarial firms submitted responsive proposals by June 25, 2018. Staff evaluated and scored the proposals on June 28, 2018. The final ranking of the firms were as follows:

1st - Foster & Foster Consulting Actuaries, Inc.
2nd - Gabriel, Roeder, Smith & Co dba GRS
3rd - USI Consulting Group
4th - AON Consulting, Inc.
5th- Gallagher Benefit Services, Inc.
6th - The Howard E. Nyhart Company, Inc. dba The Nyhart Company
6th - Boomershine Consulting Group LLC
8th - Conduent HR Consulting, LLC
9th - The Segal Company (Southeast) Inc. dba Segal Consulting/The Segal Group
10th - Bolton Partners, Inc. dba Bolton

The documentation related to the RFP is included in the back-up. Portions of the information are “claimed by bidder” to be confidential and cannot be made public.

Fi...

Click here for full text



© 2014 City of Gainesville, Florida. All right reserved.

CONTACT US
City Departments
Online Contact
200 East University Ave.
Gainesville, FL 32601
352-334-5000